The Best Eyebrow Pencil To Cover Gray Hair

Certified Senior Advisor®
Senior Home Safety Specialist®
20 years of medical equipment experience
Compassionately helping seniors and their caregivers solve challenges of aging

Just because your eyebrow hair starts to turn gray, it doesn't mean that your eyebrows shouldn’t look their best. Here are some features to look for when shopping for the best eyebrow pencil to cover your gray eyebrow hair plus a list of our favorites.

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my Income Disclosure.
Best Eyebrow Pencil To Cover Gray Hair

Your hair turns gray as you grow older, which includes the hair on your eyebrows. There could be many reasons for your eyebrow hair prematurely turning gray. A pigment imbalance is one of the most common reasons for gray eyebrow hair.

Eyebrow hair becomes darker due to a pigment produced by your body. Melanin is the pigment that makes the hair on your body darker. Melanin levels can become low due to many reasons including old age, genetics, and stress. Hormonal issues can also impact the color of your hair. Estrogen is the main hormone that affects hair discoloration. You should maintain a balanced diet to keep melanin at healthy levels.

This article provides information on some of the most important features to look for when choosing an eyebrow pencil and reviews 5 of the best products to facilitate your purchasing decision.

How to Choose an Eyebrow Pencil for Gray Hair

Anyone can use an eyebrow pencil since the range of applications for eyebrow pencils is quite diverse. An eyebrow pencil can be used to trace the contours or the entire eyebrow and cover up gray eyebrow hair – a common issue with aging.

Consider Hair and Eye Color

Eyebrow pencils are suitable for both men and women who want to hide their eyebrow grays. The type of pencil most suitable for you will depend on your hair and skin color, as well as the volume of your eyebrow hair. Make sure to consider your hair color when opting for the right eyebrow pencil. The color of your eyes also plays an important role when purchasing the best eyebrow pencil.

Choose Your Preferred Type

You have three options to choose from when shopping for the best eyebrow pencil to cover gray hair.

  • Eyebrow pencil with felt tip
  • Twist-out eyebrow pencil
  • Sharpenable eyebrow pencil

All these types of products have their own advantages and disadvantages. The eyebrow pencil with felt tips is a popular product on the market today. You will find several variations of the tips when buying this kind of product.

Most felt eyebrow pencils come with three or four tips. These products are waterproof and quite durable. One disadvantage is the pencil can dry out very quickly. The felt tip pencil is ideal on hot and sweaty days since it is waterproof.

The sharpenable pencil is great when it comes to highlighting your eyebrows. The lead is quite hard, and the application is easy. You should sharpen the pencil before each application since it’s easy to do so.

The twist-out eyebrow pencil can be twisted out as the name suggests. The lead is unscrewed via a thread at the middle or the end of the pencil. The pencil has two different ends such as a fine tip and brush. The tip helps fill even small gaps with precise hair-like strokes. The disadvantage is there is little product in the pencil which can run out quickly.

Go For Precision

The pencil should be as soft as possible for better precision. A hard pencil can be irritating on the skin and difficult to apply. For example, the pencil with a felt tip is particularly precise. On the other hand, the classic eyebrow pencil is very precise at the beginning but not guaranteed once the lead wears out.

Other Features

The hardness of the eyebrow pencil and water-resistance are two important features to consider when shopping for the best eyebrow pencil to cover gray hair. If the pencil isn’t waterproof, the makeup on the brows could quickly run.

The ingredients of the pencil are also important when shopping for the best pencil on the market. Some pencils contain critical ingredients like parabens. Parabens are criticized due to their estrogenic effect. You should opt for an eyebrow pencil without parabens.

The Best Eyebrow Pencils To Cover Gray Hair

Here are five of the best eyebrow pencils to cover gray hair:

Eye Embrace Light Gray Eyebrow Pencils

Image: Amazon API

The Eye Embrace Light Gray Eyebrow Pencil is ideal for seniors with gray, silver, or salt-peppered hair. The product lets you embrace your natural coloring with the light and medium-gray eyebrow pencils. The specially formulated gray pigments of the pencil easily blend with your natural coloring.

It’s a double-ended product with a pencil and spoolie brush. The Eye Embrace pencil is water and smudge-proof for brows that last all day long. It uses the highest quality ingredients and is cruelty, talc, and gluten-free. The diamond wedge applicator offers well-defined brows.

The product comes in two types as the mechanical pencil and the classic wooden pencil. You don’t have to sharpen the mechanical pencil, just twist it to expose the mechanical pencil. The classic wooden pencil includes a sharpener.

Where to Buy:

Laura Mercier Eye Brow Pencil

Image: Amazon API

This pencil is great for both lighter skin tones and dark shades. It’s a smoothly textured eyebrow pencil creating subtle hair-like strokes for natural-looking eyebrows. The pencil has a unique wax and powder formula to easily adhere to the skin.

The texture is firm enough to create even the tiniest lines. You will get beautiful, balanced, and natural-looking eyebrows with this eyebrow pen. The product comes with a sharpener and is safe for contact lens wearers.

Where to Buy:
Click to Compare and Save

NYX Micro Brow Pencil

Image: Amazon API

The ultra-thin NYX micro brow pencil lets you create beautiful brows and cover up the gray hair at the same time. The pencil is super precise and a great budget-friendly option for you. You can coat even the finest hairs and tinniest areas of your brows with this pencil. The product is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand.

Where to Buy:
Click to Compare and Save

Mented Cosmetics Eyebrow Pencil

Image: Amazon API

The Mented Cosmetics eyebrow pencil gives you the precise definition you require to stay put all day long. It is precision-tipped, waterproof, and will last for more than 10 hours. The Mented eyebrow pencil is a complete eyebrow kit in one pencil. It has a twist-up design on one end as well as an eyebrow spoolie on the other for easy grooming purposes.

This eyebrow makeup is vegan and doesn’t contain harmful ingredients such as fragrance, phthalates, sulfates, synthetic dyes, GMOs, gluten, and triclosan. The product comes in four natural-looking shades to complement your eye makeup with great-looking brows.

Where to Buy:
Click to Compare and Save

Glossier Brow Flick

Image: Amazon API

This is a great detailing pencil to create light and feathery strokes that are ultra-realistic. The product comes in brown, black, and blonde colors for you to choose from. It helps fill and define the brow arch, add depth to sparse areas, and extend the tail.

The pencil’s brush tip is great for creating ultra-featherlight strokes. The product is a smudge-resistant and cruelty-free brand.

Where to Buy:

Wrapping Up

If you are shopping for the best eyebrow pencil for gray hair, you have come to the right place. With a host of eyebrow pencils for gray hair, choosing the best product isn’t easy.

There are many factors to consider when doing so. We have done the homework for you and found some of the best eyebrow pencils for gray hair. This guide provides information on some of the most important features to look for when choosing an eyebrow pencil and reviews 5 of the best products to facilitate your purchasing decision.

Certified Senior Advisor (CSA)®
Senior Home Safety Specialist (SHSS)®
Assistive Technology Professional

Scott Grant has spent more than 20 years serving seniors and the elderly in the home medical equipment industry. He has worked as a manufacturer's rep for the top medical equipment companies and a custom wheelchair specialist at a durable medical equipment (DME) provider in WV. He is father to 4 beautiful daughters and has three terrific grandkids. When not promoting better living for older adults, he enjoys outdoor activities including hiking and kayaking and early morning runs.

Join Our Crew!

Enter your email address to subscribe to our weekly email newsletter to get updates on new guides for seniors and the elderly and savings on senior-friendly products. And, of course, we will never sell or share your email address!

Leave a Comment